D. Caroline Coile, Ph.D.
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Books
  • Articles
  • Contact
  • Baha Salukis
  • Surveys

A Designer Dog Book? Really?

11/5/2011

6 Comments

 
Picture

OK, out with it: The designer dog--er--elephant in the room. Or on the website. Yes, I wrote a book about designer dogs. "But how, Caroline, how could you write about those overpriced mutts that are helping bring down apple pie, dog shows and the American Kennel Club?"

It took some soul searching (and a glance at my bank statement). When I was first approached by Weldon Owen, a book packager (and we can talk the differences between book packagers and publishers in a future entry) to write it, I sighed and regretted I'd be turning them down.  I've been an AKC participant for most of my life, and I enjoy the perks my AKC dogs allow me. Writing about designer dogs seemed so traitorous.

I thought some more. I studied my bank account some more. And, as I try to do every decade or two, I opened my mind. Not everybody wants to compete. Not everybody wants one of the 150 or so AKC breeds, or even the 450 or so breeds registered elsewhere. And this IS America, home of the free, and home of the freedom to choose an AKC dog, a mutt or even a designer dog.  Withholding information is never the answer, and I'm egotistical enough to think I'm the best source of that information. Who better to present the truth about designer dogs? Who better to say we can't subtitle it "Better than  purebreds" or some other unsubstantiated claim? So I agreed. Well, yeah, I did try to convince them I should write under a pseudonym, but that was a no. Apparently my name has value. How inconvenient.

So, here's the truth about designer dogs: In some cases, they work. Look at the huskies running the Iditarod; most are mixes.  Look at the lurchers (sighthound x non-sighthound mixes) favored for poaching in Britain. The longdogs (sighthound X sighthound mixes) so successful at coyote and jackrabbit hunting in the western United States. Want to succeed at flyball? Get a BorderJack or BorderStaff or one of the other crosses bordering on insanity. Breeds, like cultures, evolve. We strive to hang on to cultural artifacts and antiques, but that doesn't mean we don't stop inventing. Every pure breed we now have was once a novel invention---perhaps even sneered at in  its infancy. 

But let's be truthful: Most designer dog breeders aren't out to make a better hunter or worker. They're out to make a better companion, and their main claim that these dogs are better (besides the fact that most are cute as h**l) is that they're healthier. 

Here's an excerpt from the book: 

When kennel clubs began registering purebreds, they allowed any dog of that general family type to be registered as the breed. At some point, registration closed, leaving a fixed number of potential sires and dams. What wasn't known at the time was that all of us, dog or human, carry from five to seven recessive genes that, if we carried two copies of any one of them, would
result in some type of hereditary disease. Because humans are a bunch of mixed breeds, we don't often end up with a mate who carries the same bad recessive gene
as we do, so it's unusual to produce an affected child. Because those early canine sires and dams carried some random bad recessives, and because all present-day purebred dogs descend from them, there's a fair chance that dogs carrying that same recessive gene might mate, creating a puppy with the disorder caused by that gene. 

The solution? Widen the breeding options, deepen the gene pools to create crossbreeds that don't share the same bad recessives. That's one argument for breeding dogs by design. The trouble is that idea works only within limits. Cross two breeds that share the same disorders and it doesn't work at all. Cross two hybrids again after the initial cross, and you're right back where you started---maybe even worse off: those hybrids will stand a good chance of carrying recessive genes and producing pups with two of the recessives and thus
two disorders. A designer dog should never be just a random mating to "see what happens." Instead, the best mixes blend breeds that can reasonably be expected
to produce desirable physical and behavioral traits.

I can't stress this enough: Just as with a purebred, your source is critical. Most of the designer dog breeders I interviewed left much to be desired in their knowledge of health or genetics. One memorable one had a clearly hydrocephalic designer dog puppy that was being touted as their poster puppy for good health; another had a puppy with a leg I swear was attached backwards! Well, it WAS a novel design...

Too many internet breeders jumped at the chance to produce puppies they could charge twice as much for as they could puppies from same-breed matings. To be fair, many purebred breeders are equally naive and money-motivated. Cave canem, buyer beware and all that. 
 
As for the book, it turned out to be one of the most beautiful  books I've been associated with--and fun. The folks at Weldon Owen were a dream to work with, my editor, Peter Cieply, made me look smart, the photography by Anna Kuperburg was stunning, the models captivating, the owners thrilled and the text gave me a chance to be both fanciful and factful (Is that a
word?). And I got to meet some pretty cool dogs!

For example, there's the Chesador, whose profile begins with:  Attaboy--shake it out! This sportsman loves a good dousing, be it from splashing along in the surf or dog-paddling around the lake. If you share the  Chesador's enthusiasm for all things active, you'll get along swimmingly...

The Jack Chi: All saunter and swagger, the Jack Chi acts like he's the biggest deal on the block. But despite his bold braggadocio and bad-boy image, he's a trickster and a charmer. And though he's happy to be scrappy, he
also craves a cuddle...

 ...And 34 other breeds, all represented by dogs who are very special to someone, and just as cherished and deserving as any purebred. 



6 Comments
Kade
11/5/2011 02:38:17 am

Well I for one was surprised to see you write this book, however you raised some important points. I've looked through the book and think that you did good educating on this topic. I'm looking foward to seeing more of what you are doing.

Reply
Sandy, about-small-dogs.com link
11/7/2011 10:44:02 am

I actually like the idea of creating new breeds. It's the same engine "juice" that moved all original breeders -- the desire to improve their dogs.
But I don't think the great majority of the designer movement people have any desire to actually create a better animal, they are simply blinded by dollar signs.
That's my beef.
If they really want to improve things, work over 10s of generations to create an improved dog that breeds true. Be the next Herr Doberman or František Horák, (who created the Cesky Terrier).
Then they will have my sincere respect.

Reply
Caroline
11/7/2011 11:14:56 am

Sandy, I tend to agree. There ARE a couple of designer dogs that I think are being bred for a purpose and will probably move from mix to breed. The Labradoodle (the ones acually bred to work) come to mind. And the Silken Windhound, so maligned 20 years ago, is now competing at ASFA lure trials and has a steady following. They fill the niche for a small, longhaired sighthound and are beautiful and biddable. It will be interesting to see the fate of the Puggle five or even ten years from now...

Reply
fast payday loans link
10/12/2013 08:45:14 pm

Success is that old ABC - ability, breaks, and courage.

Reply
interior designers link
7/29/2014 03:55:54 pm

smart interiors - one of the best modular kitchen service providers in coimbatore. They provide aluminium modular kitchen with cheap price and quality service provider in the field of modular kitchen in coimbatore.

Reply
Live Stream Quebec link
2/21/2021 06:40:53 pm

Grreat reading your blog post

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Caroline Coile

    Dog writer, science geek, Saluki savant and communicator of all things dog. I'm concerned about hereditary health problems,  the decline of purebred dogs and the changing climate of dog ownership. I compete with my Salukis in conformation, agility, lure coursing and obedience. I write about science, breeds, health and competitions---and I don't believe in blindly folllowing the accepted dogma of the dog world.

    Archives

    January 2017
    October 2016
    August 2013
    June 2013
    December 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011

    Categories

    All
    Breeds
    My Life
    My World
    Science
    Shows
    Writing

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.